Nonfiction
"A riveting study that illuminates Stevenson's profound knowledge of Scottish history and law"
(Ann Colley).
"Restores to its original brilliance Stevenson's realistic short story" (Richard Boyle, Victorian Studies).
Fiction/Nonfiction
"Menikoff's edition of Kidnapped from the autograph manuscript is only less revolutionary in its impact than his edition of The Beach of Falesá"
(Alastair Fowler, TLS).